Hungry Ghosts
Daryl BUCKLEY
Artistic Director, ELISION Ensemble
The recent opera of composer Liza LIM and librettist Beth YAHP,
Yuè Lìng Jié, derives some of its major influences from the Chinese Hungry
Ghost Festival. In Penang in the month of August it is said that the
gates of Hell are opened and that the spirits are left free to wander
the Earth. The dangerous spirits are the unappeased: those without
family or community, those left without descendants who can burn the
necessary offerings that confer status and comfort in the afterworld.
The ritual theatre undertaken at that time addresses that invisible and
normally unaddressed audience. For me, sitting in Jalan Malabar in
Georgetown in 36°C heat mid-afternoon watching fully costumed actors
give a full length operatic performance for a empty street is quite
something but then of course, the performance is for those Hungry
ghosts, as is the shrine filled with Guinness, cigarette lighters,
paper BMWs, Hell money, Hell passports and Hell airline tickets.
This performance ritual creates a border that is formed and re-opened
every year. Society for a moment addresses its own fears, the
marginalised, the chaotic anima of its darkside in a ritual before that
border is closed, the spirits returned to hell and `normality´
re-embraced.
It is the dynamic in this ritual which has most galvanised my thinking
for this brief essay. As somebody in the fortunate position of
directing an ensemble now engaged in a incredibly diverse array of
performance activities (rituals if you like) issues of coherence,
artistic development and a critical self-reflexive practice are
ongoing. In contemplating the Hungry Ghost ritual a set of questions
could be elaborated as follows -- What challenges to systems of
knowledge and practices can be posed, how are spaces defined or
elaborated in performance, and how does an audience engage in these
practices as a co-creator of significance and meaning?
For a large part of ELISION's artistic direction throughout the 1990's
a belief resided in the value of nurturing relationships between
composers and performers in a way that was analogous to that between a
choreographer and dancer. Musicians spend a long time, in fact
decades, in developing and refining a physical relationship with an
instrument. The relationship is one of posture, of establishing a
ergonomic habit that enables efficient, generally flawless and
effortless movement. There seemed to be in the writing of composers
such as Richard BARRETT or more recently in John RODGERS deployment of
a sound vocabulary utilising `degraded instruments´, a creative
intervention into that ergonomic relationship, into those very systems
of knowledge and practice galvanised around the creation of a classical
music performer.
Barrett's concept of radical instrumental writing proceeds from the
apprehension of the instrument/player combination, of trying to sculpt
musical material away to discover a existent but unexplored
compositional possibility [1]. Historical practice is borne
in mind as a special case of possible instrumentalisms, and because
`practice material' provides a kind of scale of familiarity versus
awkwardness.
Rodgers however, at least in the Inferno, a large scale work for
fourteen musicians and electronics, seems to be currently preoccupied
with re-imagining the instrument itself. His score confronts the
performer with the disturbing situation of fundamentally altering
familiar territory to such an extent that it becomes a new, deviant and
tortuous reality -- perhaps a Clive Barker-like imagination is at play
here, conceiving bizarre combinations of flesh, wood and metal? The
ice-oboe, played by Stephen ROBINSON, encapsulates this ethos most
fully. The only predictable aspect of this instrument is its demise
and the presentation to the performer of varying uncontrollable options
as the ice-oboe melts, decays and then collapses.
Also in the Inferno there are the gestural constellations of a cellist,
Rosanne HUNT, having her 'cello's neck bowed in such a way as to imply
a cutting of her throat, the tangle of arms and bows as three people
perform/ attack the same radically de-tuned viola of Erkki VELTHEIM,
and the near Dylanesque engagement of percussionist Peter NEVILLE's
mouth and limbs with an array of dog whistles, flexatones, bowed and
pedal operated water crotales.
All of these performance techniques emerge out of Rodgers' own personal
experimentation. In his improvisations John has displayed no reticence
in using his violin to bow a classical guitar or in unwinding his
violin bow and twisting the hair in a spiral around the wood, the
resulting combination of both wood and hair then being employed to
produce strange articulations on his violin. Such interrogation of the
performer/instrument relationship applied wholesale to an ensemble
willing to commit itself to such investigation, inevitably creates its
own dramaturgy. The concentration and effort that each moment of
performance requires are monumental and not without a resultant visual
vocabulary. Certainly it seems to me that one of Rodgers' intentions
in the Inferno is to throw musicians back upon their own core
resources, simultaneously acknowledging the depth of established skill
while using unfamiliar challenges to directly tap into the energies and
acumen that generated that depth. The constant flux in that work
between notated and improvisational modes makes those challenges even
more acute.
I have found that these composers, amongst others, who work with
introducing disturbances into considered practice, provide an
interesting fault line in locating ELISION's practice. One intention
is the transformation of the concert hall format from a `one-off event´
into a process driven outcome emerging from a very complex set of
longterm artistic relationships.
Herein can lie one of the most earth shattering requests that can be
made of an audience in current contemporary art practice -- that is, the
requirement of `listening´ without distraction! And here the European
concert-hall format, often considered to be the boring platform of a
unthinking non-reflective high arts practice, can transform itself into
something quite subversive. It is this aspect of ELISION activities in
rethinking concert-hall practice that brings coherence with the
ensemble's engagement in music-theatre, visual arts and site-specific
installation.
In those collaborations utilising found spaces to generate a
performance practice a criteria I always use is `what does it feel like
to be in that space at that moment hearing that sound, having that
visual experience´? The most profound theatre, the only one in fact,
is the human mind. One of the lessons of the first Bar-do'i-thos-grol
installation project (premiered by ELISION in 1994) [2]
for me was the
simplicity of technical means that visual artist Domenico De CLARIO
employed to create perceptual doorways into the existent but unnoticed
-- seven coloured floodlights, a suspended chandelier and the choice of
their placement amongst the ruins of cars and household materials. In
this project De Clario's work relentlessly positions itself as a subtle
intervention into established borders, a breaking of the framed act
that constitutes a barrier between art and non-art with importance
being re-centred on the audience's perceptual abilities in the creation
of the work and the subsequent potential for the re-evaluation of their
own experience, history and knowledge.
Another analogue: the qin, the Chinese zither, is an extremely quiet
instrument whose performance was traditionally heard only in intimate
circumstances. The listener is embraced as a co-creator of musical
meaning and their inner space is as important to the performance as the
actions of the performer. The qin is an instrument to be played to a
listener, here defined as the perfect and true friend (not defined as
that ubiquitous funding statistic -- the bum on a seat).
A more recent ELISION project realised presented at the Queensland Art
Gallery's Third Asia Pacific Triennial of Visual Art was
Sonorous Bodies (1999). This installation-performance project takes its
framework from the aesthetics of qin performance. Here the `true
friend´ entered the performance space (the Old Library of Brisbane
Town Hall) through a eight metre blacked-out tunnel. To enter you had
to allow time for your eyes to adjust to the limited ambient light, to
allow time to attend to the necessarily slow and quiet navigation of
that tunnel into a wider series of spaces which contained eight
different video projections (artist Judith WRIGHT) and a performance by
the Koto player Satsuki ODAMURA of music by composer Liza LIM.
Both Judith and Liza embrace similar sensibilities for perception of
the deflected, the action and moment of touch, the sensing of
vibrations set in motion through projected light.
Lament of Desire (first performed by ELISION for the 1999 Perth
Festival) was another video-installation project, involving
collaboration between the Thai visual artist Araya RASDJARMREARNSOOK,
composer Timothy O'DWYER and musicians of the ELISION ensemble. In the
colonial sandstone Fremantle prison, films of a morgue in Chiang Mai
with images of the artist reading to dead bodies, and of corpses
floating in water were projected into six ponds of water. The
musicians were visually anonymous, hidden to the audience, situated
high on top of internal mechanical and wooden structures. The audience
placed themselves on seats along the wall or wandered around the ponds,
reflections of their own peering faces mixed in with those of the
gently floating Thai dead.
In performance Araya read from a Thai text called the
Inaow. The sound of her readings also emanated from the
video-projections (as did the sounds of the fans in that Chiang Mai
morgue), and were sampled and processed electronically from one night
of performance to the next. The core of this work, in its confluence
of multiple spaces, visual and sonic presences, is Araya's chanting to
the dead as a invitation back into life. Here the ghosts are
acknowledged as permanent co-existences, invited back into life without
ritual closure.
The Inaow was a text read at school everyday during Araya's
education.
Like many traditional writings it encodes a set of behaviour between
genders, friends, and family with respect to the ideal of love. The
discrepancy between these social strictures and the reality of
contemporary urban life in Bangkok introduces a powerful unresolved
dissonance in counterpoint to the above.
Timothy O'Dwyer's Sige for solo bass saxophone and prerecorded
materials (1999), commissioned by the Queensland Art Gallery to
celebrate their acquisition of the sculpture Void (13#) by
Anish Kapoor, draws heavily upon Kapoor's strategies for suggesting
the void.
The artist's use of pigments, organic materials, and sculptured forms
are tactically duplicitous; the eye is defeated as it gazes upon this
particular work and the longer the duration of the focus, the more
intense this failed subjectivity becomes. Like an automated projector
unable to establish itself in relation to an image, the viewer cannot
easily take a position with respect to the Kapoor.
Likewise O'Dwyer's use of trilled multiphonics, harmonics, circular
breathing, and vocalisations both disturb and create unusual patterns
of difference tones within a heavily polyphonic performance style. He
consciously creates within the listener a sense of multiplicity that in
its very ceaselessness elicits a sonic uniformity of texture as
enveloping as is Kapoor's Void (13#).
The issues of a critical self-reflexive practice, the location of the
performance space as a site for interarts practice, inter and
intracultural collaboration, and the perceptual relationship of
audience to work, all elaborate, inform and construct ELISION's
investigation of existing and new modes of performance practice.
Referenced as they are to historicised practice, Euro-American models
(examples such as the London Sinfonietta, Ensemble InterContemporain
or even Het trio) that have struggled to survive in their derivative
forms are no longer adequate within an Australian environment, if
indeed they ever were, and are fundamentally disabling for the
contextualisation of work within the set of broader concerns, the
multiplicity of narratives that articulate the Asia-Pacific region.
These include issues of identity, globalism, migration,
post-colonialism, and intercultural conflict. Like-wise attention to
these issues can assist in providing an artistic response to engagement
within Europe. A fundamental question here is what is being added to,
suggested, or what contribution is being made to international ensemble
practice and discourse. The ghosts are hungry and demand attention if
not a feast!!!
- Richard Toop.
Richard Barrett in interview.
Sounds Australian, Autumn 1991, page 27.
- Domenico de Clario and Liza Lim.
the intertwining--the chasm.
Brisbane, Institute of Modern Art, 1998.
Further reading:
- Robert Davidson.
Sacred Geometry: Interview with John Rodgers.
Realtime issue 36.
- Charles Green.
Peripheral Visions--Contemporary Australian Art 1970-1994.
Craftsman House, 1995.
|